Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez apologizes for blocking a critic on Twitter and settles a lawsuit charging that she violated the First Amendment




Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez apologizes for blocking a critic on Twitter and settles a lawsuit charging that she violated the First Amendment
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez apologizes for blocking a critic on Twitter and settles a lawsuit charging that she violated the First Amendment  

Associated Press

  • Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez reached a settlement in a lawsuit filed by former Brooklyn Assemblyman Dov Hikind, who accused the lawmaker of violating the First Amendment by blocking him on Twitter.

  • In a statement obtained by Insider, Ocasio-Cortez said on Monday that Hikind was exercising his constitutionally-protected right to free speech by criticizing her on Twitter. She unblocked him.

  • "In retrospect, it was wrong and improper and does not reflect the values I cherish. I sincerely apologize for blocking Mr. Hikind," she said.

  • But the congresswoman insisted that she won't refrain from blocking accounts in the future that she believes are engaging in improper harassment.

  • Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories.

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez reached a settlement in a lawsuit filed by former Brooklyn Assemblyman Dov Hikind, who accused the lawmaker of violating the First Amendment by blocking him on Twitter.

In a statement obtained by Insider, Ocasio-Cortez said on Monday that she had "reconsidered" her decision to block Hikind from her account. She conceded that Hikind, an outspoken conservative, was exercising his constitutionally-protected right to free speech by criticizing her on Twitter.

The announcement, first reported by the New York Post, comes just one day before Ocasio-Cortez was scheduled to testify in federal court in Brooklyn.

"Mr. Hikind has a First Amendment right to express his views and should not be blocked for them," she said. "In retrospect, it was wrong and improper and does not reflect the values I cherish. I sincerely apologize for blocking Mr. Hikind."

The lawmaker, who has 5.7 million Twitter followers, previously defended her decision to block about 20 Twitter users from her personal account because she argued that their online behavior amounted to harassment.

"Harassment is not a viewpoint," Ocasio-Cortez tweeted in August. "Some accounts, like the Daily Caller, posted fake nude photos of me & abused my comments to spread it. No one is entitled to abuse."

In her Monday statement, the congresswoman insisted that she won't refrain from blocking accounts from following her or reading her tweets in the future when she believes the users have engaged in improper harassment.

"Now and in the future, however, I reserve the right to block users who engage in actual harassment or exploit my personal/campaign account, @AOC, for commercial or other improper purposes," she said.

Ocasio-Cortez's move is a surprising about-face, given that she publicly defended her decision to block users just a few months ago. A source close to the lawmaker also recently defended her attempts to block users who reply to her tweets with provocative comments as a way to boost their following.

"I think not letting right-wing trolls use you as a springboard to elevate their hateful platform is a fine thing to do," the source told Insider in October. "It's not even really about her hearing it or seeing the vitriol. It's about using - clout chasers."

Some prominent First Amendment experts have urged Ocasio-Cortez in recent months to reverse her decision to block critics on the social media platform.

"Many of your tweets staking out positions on issues such as immigration, the environment, and impeachment have made headline news," Columbia University's Knight First Amendment Institute wrote in a letter to the congresswoman. "The @AOC account is important to you as a legislator, to your constituents, and to others who seek to understand and influence your legislative decisions and priorities."

Legal precedent wasn't in Ocasio-Cortez's favor. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals ruled unanimously in July that President Donald Trump is violating the First Amendment by blocking critics from his Twitter account. The government petitioned for re-hearing in August.

The appeals court held that when the president and other public officials use online forums like Twitter for government business, they transform them into public forums subject to First Amendment protections.

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals similarly ruled last January that a local elected official in Virginia violated the First Amendment when she blocked a constituent on Facebook for 12 hours.

  • Read more:

  • Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez blocked a conservative news outlet on Twitter, and legal experts say that could be unconstitutional

  • Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez says she has the right to block critics on social media - a court ruling against Trump suggests she might not

  • Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez says the revenge porn campaign targeting Rep. Katie Hill is a 'major crime' that wouldn't happen to a male member of Congress

NOW WATCH: Extremists turned a frog meme into a hate symbol, but Hong Kong protesters revived it as an emblem of hope

COMMENTS

More Related News

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez blasts Trump administration for cuts to food stamps, sharing that her family
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez blasts Trump administration for cuts to food stamps, sharing that her family 'might've just starved' without them

Ocasio-Cortez said in a tweet that her family once relied on the program when her father died, and without it, they may have starved.

Biden Claims the Media Inflated AOC
Biden Claims the Media Inflated AOC's Role as Party Leader: 'You Guys Got it All Wrong'

Former Vice President Joe Biden is accusing the media of "bad judgment" in their coverage of progressive Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, saying reporters and commentators have exaggerated her political rise as indicative of the direction of the overall party."You guys got it all wrong about what happened," Biden told Axios on HBO in Iowa."You sound like Trump. Fake news?" host Mike Allen remarked."I do," Biden responded. "It's not fake. It's just bad judgment.""You all thought that what happened was the party moved extremely to the left after Hillary. AOC was the new party," Biden continued. "She's a bright,...

Chirp debuts a faster, feature-filled Twitter app for Apple Watch
Chirp debuts a faster, feature-filled Twitter app for Apple Watch

Chirp, a Twitter client preferred by hundreds of thousands of Apple Watch users, is getting its biggest upgrade since its arrival last year. Now redesigned for watchOS 6, the new version of Chirp includes a rebuilt timeline feature that allows you to endlessly scroll through tweets much more quickly than before, along with other enhancements like support for iOS 13's dark mode and a way to add colors to your Twitter username. The app was first introduced to fill the void created when Twitter pulled its own Apple Watch app back in 2017 in favor of using Apple Watch's notifications platform instead.

Elon Musk testifies at defamation trial he responded to
Elon Musk testifies at defamation trial he responded to 'unprovoked attack'

High-tech entrepreneur Elon Musk took the witness stand at his defamation trial on Tuesday, testifying that his inflammatory Twitter message at the center of the case was sent in response to an "unprovoked" insult he received from the man now suing him. The diver, Vernon Unsworth, says Musk, who also founded the rocket company SpaceX, falsely labeled him a pedophile on Twitter and should pay punitive and other damages for harming Unsworth's reputation. The case stems from an offer Musk made to furnish a mini-submarine from SpaceX to assist in the cave rescue in July 2018.

Last GOP bastions in suburban NYC face a difficult question: Do they even mention Trump?
Last GOP bastions in suburban NYC face a difficult question: Do they even mention Trump?

Republicans in Nelson Rockefeller's Westchester, watching as their party wanes in local politics, avoid talking about the president.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Latin America