3 Libra questions Congress should ask Facebook's Zuckerberg




  • In Business
  • 2019-10-14 14:34:19Z
  • By Decrypt
3 Libra questions Congress should ask Facebook\
3 Libra questions Congress should ask Facebook\'s Zuckerberg  


Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg's appearance before Congress on October 23 is an opportunity for lawmakers to find out more about Libra.

Since its launch this past June, Facebook's idea for a cryptocurrency that spans its social network has drawn opprobrium and criticism from legislators and international organizations around the world. This is partly due to its lack of details.

While it released a tranche of Libra documentation in June, Facebook has revealed little about the coin afterwards. Even Libra co-creator David Marcus' appearance before Congress in July failed to provide answers.

Zuckerberg's appearance will allow Congress to pull back the curtains on an ambitious project that could have significant implications for the world economy. Here are three questions that lawmakers should ask him when they face off next week.

1. Who regulates Libra?

When he appeared before Congress, Libra co-creator and chief David Marcus insisted that the blockchain and cryptocurrency would take into account concerns from regulators around the world before its launch.

But it is difficult to identify the appropriate regulators, given the breadth and absence of details about its operations. Rep. Katie Porter (D-CA) encapsulated the problem in one of her remarks during the previous Congressional hearing. "I am not sure if this [Libra] is a problem for my investor protection subcommittee or my consumer protection subcommittee," she said.

When extrapolated on a global stage, the regulation problem multiplies. In previous interviews, Libra co-creator Marcus has stated that developers who create apps on its blockchain are responsible for complying with laws in their respective jurisdictions. It is an approach used by other crypto businesses, such as Localbitcoins, a peer-to-peer money transfer mechanism.

Stripe, eBay, Mastercard and Visa quit Facebook's Libra

The problem, at least in Facebook's case, is that it is held to a higher standard. This is primarily because its massive geographical reach multiplies the scope of Libra's operations. In a centralized system of money transfers, financial services providers, such as PayPal, assume responsibility for such operations because they provide the rails to make it happen.

That is not possible in a decentralized system. As an example, the division of responsibility is unclear in a money-laundering case where a payment app situated in a jurisdiction that may not comply with AML/KYC obligations transmits money using Libra to another, similar entity.

2. How does Libra plan to distribute its tokens?

Based on the documentation released so far, Libra is intended to be distributed through authorized resellers. Besides the fact that this practice further centralizes Libra operations, the mechanics and requirements to become a reseller are not known. This is important because an authorized reseller plays an important role in the Libra ecosystem, similar to the one played by commercial banks in an economy.

Interestingly CoinFLEX, a futures platform, recently released futures contracts for betting on a date for Libra's launch. The contracts are physically-settled and traders will receive Libra tokens equivalent to the amount of their bet upon expiration. News of the contract raises an important question. Is CoinFLEX an authorized reseller of the token or has it applied to become one? Either way, the answer to that question might provide clues to the functioning and place of authorized resellers within the Libra ecosystem.

3. Is Libra a security?

Libra is planned to be governed by the Libra Association, a consortium of established companies and non-profits who will each contribute $10 million to its reserves. They are also responsible for running mining nodes that will mine Libra's coin which will have "low volatility." The association plans to make periodic payouts to them for their investment.

The current set of arrangements potentially makes Libra a security, per the SEC's definition, which is based on the Howey test. The test uses four prongs-an investment contract, expectation of profits, use of a third party for promotion, and the existence of a common enterprise-to determine whether a token is a security.

The Libra Association could be construed as a common enterprise, and the existence of low volatility in Libra's price could ensure profits for its members. While he refused to comment specifically on Libra, SEC Chairman Jay Clayton told lawmakers at a hearing recently that it "sounds like a security."

Congress should get to the heart of Libra's functioning to find out more about how Facebook plans to incentivize Libra Association members and developers for its proposed blockchain.


COMMENTS

More Related News

People smugglers use YouTube to teach migrants how to illegally enter UK in refrigerator trucks
People smugglers use YouTube to teach migrants how to illegally enter UK in refrigerator trucks
  • US
  • 2019-11-17 21:25:00Z

Migrants are using social media to teach people how to enter the UK illegally in refrigerated lorries as in the Essex container tragedy, as police chiefs demand tech giants crackdown on the posts. The illegal migrants are flagrantly posting YouTube videos including a teenager in the back of a refrigerated truck boasting that he is just 40 minutes from England.  Talking to camera, the shivering teenage migrant says: "I thank God who has helped me but to all of you who think to make the same journey to England, it's very difficult. We hope God will help us when we go to England, it is hard this refrigerator." Another video published on March 2019 on Youtube shows a migrant lying face down...

Michigan man shoots brother after mistaking him for hurt deer
Michigan man shoots brother after mistaking him for hurt deer
  • US
  • 2019-11-17 21:14:00Z

A man shot his brother after mistaking him for an injured deer in a hunting accident in Michigan on Saturday. The incident occurred after the men went looking for a deer that one brother had shot earlier with a muzzle-loading rifle, reported the Ionia County Sheriff's Office on its Facebook page. The shooter, a 29-year-old man from Saranac, told authorities that he believed he saw the deer moving and fired, but after firing realized he had struck his 28-year-old brother.

Bored of the coins
Bored of the coins

Something strange is afoot in the world of cryptocurrencies. For the first time since Satoshi dropped Bitcoin on us like a benevolent bomb, this painfully new, highly bizarre field has become ... well ... boring.

Disabled Woman
Disabled Woman's Boyfriend Told Police He Lured Her to Nevada Desert and Suffocated Her

Bethel Park PoliceA Maryland man who may have been leading a double life has confessed to kidnapping his disabled girlfriend, luring her into the Nevada desert, tying her to a signpost and suffocating her with duct tape, police said Friday.He allegedly then pretended to be the victim on Facebook, sending her family messages to cover up her disappearance until friends reported her missing earlier this week.Jaime Rae Feden, 33, suffered from a rare congenital condition called VATER syndrome and stood just over 4 feet tall. Authorities said the Bethel Park, Pennsylvania, woman was sweet-natured and trusting.Too trusting."She was a very loving type of a person and I think she was taken...

Vietnam jails music teacher for
Vietnam jails music teacher for 'undermining' state

Vietnam sentenced a music teacher to 11 years in prison on Friday for Facebook posts that allegedly undermined the one-party state, which has been accused of tightening the noose on online dissent. Communist Vietnam has long jailed its critics but has come under fire recently for targeting users on Facebook, a popular forum for activists in the country where all independent media is banned. Nguyen Nang Tinh is the latest activist jailed for his Facebook comments, including posts about a Taiwanese steel firm that dumped toxic sludge into the ocean, killing masses of fish in central Vietnam.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Business